This is a complex question with varying perspectives. Here's a breakdown of the arguments:
Arguments Against Taking Communion from a Lying Pastor:
* Integrity of the Sacrament: Communion is a sacred act representing unity with Christ and fellow believers. A pastor who is actively lying or living in unrepentant sin damages the integrity of the sacrament. Their actions contradict the spiritual truths it symbolizes.
* Potential for Hypocrisy: Participating in communion led by someone who is not living in accordance with Christian principles can feel hypocritical. It may create a sense of unease or discomfort.
* Spiritual Harm: Some believe that taking communion from someone who is not in right standing with God could have negative spiritual consequences.
* Support of Wrongdoing: By participating in the service and taking communion, you might be seen as tacitly supporting or condoning the pastor's behavior.
* Personal Conscience: Many believe that your personal conscience and discernment play a key role. If you feel uneasy or that it is wrong, it is best to listen to that feeling.
Arguments For Taking Communion Even from a Lying Pastor:
* Focus on Christ: The focus of communion is on Christ's sacrifice, not the person administering it. The elements (bread and wine) are consecrated and symbolize Christ's body and blood, regardless of the pastor's personal failings.
* Personal Relationship with God: Communion is a personal act of faith and connection with God. Your relationship with God is not dependent on the worthiness of the pastor.
* Church Unity: Refusing to take communion could cause division and disruption within the church community.
* Forgiveness and Grace: Christianity emphasizes forgiveness and grace. Just as individuals are flawed, so are church leaders.
* God's Sovereignty: Some believe that God can work through imperfect people and situations.
Additional Considerations:
* Nature and Extent of the Lie: The severity and nature of the pastor's dishonesty matter. A minor, unintentional white lie is different from a pattern of deception or serious misconduct.
* Church's Response: Is the church aware of the situation? Are they taking steps to address it? If the church is actively working to resolve the issue, it may be more appropriate to continue participating in communion.
* Alternative Options: If you are uncomfortable taking communion at your current church, consider finding another church where you feel more spiritually aligned.
Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to take communion from a lying pastor is a personal one. Consider these factors, pray for guidance, and follow your conscience. You might also seek counsel from trusted Christian friends, mentors, or other church leaders.